I never thought I’d want to learn to be a tango boy. I mean, why (in heaven’s name) would I when I can get bliss, and feel like the most desirable woman on the planet whenever I want, in the arms of men?
But that was before I got a bee in my bonnet about passing on (to my fellow Brits who want to feel deeper connections in their tango abrazos) what I’ve learned from the milongueros I love the most, on the subject of tango heaven. I can never quite graduate to be a man, so I can never feel what a milonguero feels as he embraces a woman, but perhaps by putting myself in their steps I can glimpse a few clues to their mastery. At least, that’s my enthusiastic-Sallycat/Barbie theory.
The practice has been one month (so far) of two, hour-long, private-lessons each week with my own master-teacher, Ariel Yanovsky. He originally taught me how to be a woman in tango, clean and classy, salon-style. Then, the milongueros got their hands on me, and took the pivot out and put the could-be-termed-bad-habits-by-the-Villa-Urquiza-buffs in (‘cos the dance floors are packed in BsAs, the steps are short-ish, and the hip-wiggles feel gorgeous to both them and to me). Now, having said Extend, slide, arrive to my female-tango-dancer a zillion times, Ariel is teaching me to do something else entirely in order to ‘be the boy’.
I gave him a bit of a challenge. One month, because we’ll be in different countries for a long time after that. Teach me enough so that I can spend the months ahead practising my boy-technique and building my boy dance skills and dance-floor-navigation skills. Shall I do three classes a week? I asked. And he said, No, and explained that we’d be covering a lot of ground fast, and I’d be better to spend some time practising with a friend to allow my body to absorb and remember what I was learning in the lessons. One day you’ll ‘get’ things and the next day you’ll forget them, then one day the ‘penny will drop’ (yep, he knows that phrase in English) and your body will finally understand… might be soon but more likely it’ll be a while ahead. I knew exactly what he meant. I’m already a tango dancer, and I understand something of my process of learning to dance, where body tends to lag behind mind. I’m a hell of a lot more relaxed than I was during month one the first time round; I don’t freak out when I can’t ‘get something’ I’m being taught, I know it’s a process, just like any other learned skill or new behaviour. Plus, this time it’s more important to me to enjoy myself than anything else. “Dancing tango” and “learning new stuff” are on my Joy List, after all.
Tango mujer (foto by Helen Coyle)
Tango boy (foto by Ariel Yanovsky)
I am slightly shocked to find out how distant ‘learning to be the tango boy’ feels from ‘learning to be the tango woman’. It just doesn’t seem like the same dance at all… Thinking versus voiding the mind. The need for decisive action (even if it is a pause) versus the choice to surrender. Calculation versus invited response. I am shocked, but I rather like it. But I think my reaction is more awe and wonder than anything else. Frankly, learning to be the boy appeals to the achiever in me, the problem solver in me, the mathematical and logical and analytical mind in me, the musician in me, and it offers me exploration of opposite sides of my being, the yin yang of me. Yet, the whole experience makes me acutely aware that, as the Wikipedia entry for yin yang says, Opposites only exist in relation to each other. In this learning experience, most definitely. Knowing the girl side of the coin makes me curious about the boy side and leaves me clapping with excitement at the differences I am discovering. Had I only ever learned the boy part, perhaps I’d be giving up already at the amount of decision-making involved. Now, I’m just in awe of how my favourite male dancers do what they do. They are utter geniuses. And I am hooked. I have to know more of their secrets.
In my classes, Ariel teaches me technique, foundation steps that I can link together to build my dance, awareness of the direction of the dance and the ronda, how to stay safe and how to cope with obstacles. He checks I understand everything we do by testing me, making me say what I will do before I do it, asking me to explain what happens when things go differently to what I expect. As we work I know he sees the cogs of my mind turning and meeting and pausing and puzzling and finally dancing. I think I surprise him with my processing and implementation of all that he teaches. He says Very good! a lot (which he rarely did when I was learning to be the girl). I say, No, wait! Don’t tell me. Let me work it out! a lot. Our hands meet in ‘high fives’ at the end of each lesson and I hug him, exclaiming, Wow! It’s amazing! I can’t believe I did that… but I did.
Me and my talented teacher, Ariel
The prácticas with my girlfriends are kinda funny. I go to El Beso where there is a pillar in the centre of the dance floor. It’s a relatively calm práctica, so there is only one lane… well, one lane… and me dancing round the pillar; it seems full of magnetic energy that pillar, leastwise it seems to attract me. Still it’s helping me too, because as long as it’s drawing me in, I’m not banging into the other couples dancing outside me. Actually, at the ends of tandas, there have been a few high fives between me and my partners (one or two of which have been men; and one even said that he had rarely seen me as happy).
In the beginning of learning to dance as a woman, tango eased my then-tormented mind, gave me a safe place to become beautiful for the first time in my life, and allowed me to connect via my darker edge to release my inner glow. I’m learning to be the boy at a time when I have already connected with my spirit, so maybe it’d feel different if I hadn’t. But, my first impressions are that, in my case, since I am really a girl, being the boy is a lighter experience than being the woman was. It feels more like a game to me than a serious matter. It seems more of a mental challenge than a physical one because my body already understands the fundamentals of tango. It wakens my mind and leaves it buzzing, whereas as normally tango surges through my body and leaves my mind soothed in the wake of its rush.
As a writer, there is so much I want to share of my learning. How does the power I feel as a tango-boy differ to the power I feel as a tango-woman? What do I feel when I hold another female in my embrace? What depth of connection is possible when I, a girl, am dancing as a boy? That’s all to come in Parts 2, 3, 4 and beyond of On learning to be the tango boy, when you are really a girl.
Andreas, David, Steve and David, congrats from me and Barbie, and a zillion thanks for having put a bit more ‘Happy Tango’ energy in my 2010/2011 UK days. Guys, you rock!
ABBBA awarded to Andreas for masterminding (with his wonderful woman Lynn and his Tangokombinat colleagues) the first ever “Festival of Social Tango” to be held in the UK, on 6th 7th and 8th May 2011; the website gives the following details: 3 days and 2 nights of dancing await aficionados of social tango. Over three days you can take part in workshops with some of the best salón teachers available, work with friends in guided and open prácticas, or sit, chat and dance in the Hex, our central all-day meeting place. At the milongas, you will be dancing late into the night to the best Golden Age tango music chosen by excellent DJs. Sounds super, doesn’t it? I’ve been in touch with Andreas in the lead up to the Event’s launch, and think it’s a unique and exciting happening that lovers of social tango will not want to miss; I even asked him whether girls dancing as boys will be welcome, and he says Yes, Abrazos will smile on anyone who embraces their fellow dancers with love, friendship and respect. Perfect. Book prontísimo, before places sell out!
ABBBA awarded to David for bringing to the UK (and international) market great, beautiful and worthy men’s tango shoes, a pair of which have been bought, worn and much loved by Carlos (and are shown, in the pics above, on his feet, which you can tell are Argentine because of the gaucho trousers — luverly aren’t they?). The Vidadance shoes are stylish, well-crafted, well-priced, and there is even a simple foot-sizing system available on the website which actually works for ordering online – Carlos got the right size first time, without trying on the shoes before he bought. Brilliant!
ABBBA awarded to Steve for his exciting and original work in the field of development of musicality in tango dancers; especially, his weekly workshops in Advanced Musicality at Bramshaw Tango (which I would love to attend one day), and this brilliantly clear and effective chart of tango orchestras through time (click here and go to Page 6 for full details). Steve has always been an inspiration to me because of the strength, passion and generosity in his tango heart, the wide range and quality of the tango events that he runs with his wonderful wife Debbie, and the musical genius that he brings to the British tango page. Have you heard the music he improvised as a theme for the Happy Hearts Quest? No? Click inside the box where it says ‘1. Pure Happy Hearts’ to listen and see how beautifully it beckons you to join The Quest for Joy that I’ve founded on Facebook for 2011. It’s fab, and so is Steve!
ABBBA awarded to David for his masterful development (together with his wonderful partner Alison, and assisted by the super teaching of his resident teacher Sharon Koch) of a thriving UK social tango community with a core of capable yet refreshingly humble male-dancers at its warm heart (and the women are fantastic too). I still have to pinch myself that a tango community of the quality and strength of Shrewsbury Tango exists in the very same town where I live when I am in the UK. It is as if someone put Dave and Alison and their Thursday practicas and Monday men’s sessions right here in Shrewsbury, just for Me and C.! I do not think any tango community could have welcomed us more warmly, and the fact that Dave is of such similar tango mind to me, is surely heaven-sent. And even better, David says the same about me (!), which makes me certain that The Universe has had a hand in our meeting and working together. I’m going to be running workshops, on the theme of connection, for David’s tango community in the summer, and I’m very excited about that.
The joy in my boy tango-embrace (Thanks G.)
Ah, how marvellous that learning to ‘be the boy’ has caused me to pause and consider then men of the tango I adore. And not just the men I dance with, but all the tango men past, present and future who add their spirit to every step I walk on the male side of the dance. Guys, by dancing in your tango shoes for a while, I wish that I may I understand you and know you better, and appreciate you even more than I already do.
The lovely trophy image above was originally on the web at dealbreaker.com
Hi Sal, It looks like you are really enjoying your gender change(Tango related) I must admit that when I have tried the same but in reverse so to speak I have found it enjoyable but scary…Trying to change your mind set is from active to almost passive needs practice.. Maybe we can dance on this trip at some time one I lead and one you lead it would be interesting….Hope Mum is on the Mend and hope to see you soon lots of luv and hugs JB
Hello JB, apols for delay in reply – bit full on in Shrewsbury… Mum up and down, but it is so great to be with her and don’t want to miss a minute!
I find dancing the guy a heck of a challenge, especially when I am tired because I have to work very hard (as you say) to switch from the role and feel and walk I know so well, and love so much! A whole new set of body memories need to be laid down. I’m also finding that I prefer dancing to the more lyrical tangos, as the boy, because they tend to give me more time to think! D’Arienzo becomes pretty scary as it races along and I get worn out!
Yes, perhaps one day we shall dance ’swapped over’ – in the summer as probably not travelling at all this time round, though I confess I find being the boy is easier with girls rather than guys – in part because I can see over their shoulders
Big hug, SC
Its me again just to say that your Barbie Awards are well placed.. Andreas is a great teacher and has helped us so much over the last year. Davids shoes are never far from me, and my feet love them. Steves innovation and development is always intersting,and unfortunatly I know very little about David in Shrewsbury but I am sure that one day we will get up there and meet..
lv JB
Thank you JB. Do come to Shrewsbury (Thursdays) one day if you are ever passing through the ‘north-ish’, or maybe to the milonga at Pant http://tangoin.co.uk/?page_id=29. Very friendly crowd and wonderfully committed to the social dance.
SC
Thanks for the shout-out, Sally! I happily share the award with my wonderful woman Lynn, who has created Abrazos with me and is driving things forward unceasingly.
Thanks also to the Tangokombinaters across the channel, and the numerous people helping, as well as to the Continentals making the hop.
Oh, and next time we meet at a milonga, you can lead me!
Hi Andreas, delighted to celebrate you and Lynn (who I have now added to my post!) and the Tangokombinaters. I hope that Abrazos will be the first of many such events and that I will be at the next one.
Perhaps by then I will be up to leading at a milonga – not quite there yet…
Abrazos! SC
Hi “Tango Boy”,
I can’t wait for the part 2 —–I may even decide to get more classes as a “tango boy”.
My experience as leader started 2 years ego and changed the way I view tango.Thank you so very much and keep me updated in the future.
Best tango hugs,
-Ewa
Hello Ewa, thanks so much for your comment.
‘Being the tango boy’ is definitely changing, and I think deepening, the way I view tango, though I am quite concerned to not let it affect too much how I dance as a woman – I’m kind of monitoring that a bit, as I don’t want to lose that incredible feeling of voiding out and letting go and surrender… it is so special, and I think, good for me.
I’ll definitely write more on this topic, and I do hope you will enjoy reading what I have to say. I can’t imagine where ‘my boy dancer’ will get to in two years, but I am excited to find out!
Warm tango hug, SC
Ah Sal!
Another great and insightful post. And it’s so refreshing to hear someone who celebrates the guys!!
And those differences between the leader and the follower are so important…… if you both enter the dance trying (conciously or unconciously) to take on the ’same role’ then conflict, rather than harmony, are likely to ensue.
Keep up the good work girl!
xxxxxxxxx
Yes Charlotte, the one thing I am slightly wary of, is the ‘boy stuff’ affecting my ‘girl stuff’. I love what I have found by dancing the women – my woman – and I do not want to lose that woman I have unleashed; she is fab!
I do sooooooooo celebrate the guys, because if it hadn’t been for their care and skill, I would never have discovered my woman. I will be forever grateful.
I am so happy you are reading, and I will keep dancing and writing, as at the moment I am loving both more than ever.
Warmest of hugs, SC
Fascinating stuff, as ever. It’s amazing how you manage to write so clearly about something that is just so hard to write about (writing about dance being a bit like singing about architecture, or something!) especially with never a cliche in sight.
I’m looking forward to more El Beso practicas. Lots of love Hx
Gracias my dear H.
Your words on my writing make me smile broadly. It is an exciting challenge for me to see if I can really convey what I want to say about my dance experiences, and writing this blog for over four years now has helped me to do it more confidently.
The El Beso practicas, so grateful to you for introducing me to them – they are a great end to our Mondays, though it seems our Mondays will be changing yet again… hope that if you went yesterday, it was fun.
See you soooooooon for lots of dancing. Yes! SC
Thank you all for the fantastic, helpful comments.
My two cents:
Seems the transition from follower to leader /and vice versa / starts with…..
1.changing shoes,
2.reseatting my mind how I LISTEN to the music / to avoid anticipation as a follower and
initiate the interpretation of music as a leader /,
3.not to CONFUSE leading with active following,
Hugs,
-Ewa
> a thriving UK social tango community …
> I still have to pinch myself that a tango community
> of the quality and strength of Shrewsbury Tango exists…
Sally, the heart of a thriving tango community is the milonga. While yours has no milongas, just classes, I must say I think your award is somewhat premature.
This post is fantastic! I love that you are learning to be a tango boy:) I haven’t checked in for a while and I missed quite a few posts so I’m catching up but thanks as always for sharing your experiences with your lovely words:) And I hope everything is continuing to go well with your mom and that she is healing and happy:)
Christine in LA, so glad you checked in! Sorry to be an age replying, got my Mum on my mind at the mo and am a bit distracted here in the UK.
My blog posts may be less frequent these days, but I do enjoy waiting for a topic to build in my mind and then when it is bursting from me, I write! Plus of course I am writing for the HHQ, so it will be great to connect there also. Do keep reading when your life allows, I will always be delighted to find you here.
Big abrazo to you, SC
Hi Sally,
I really enjoyed reading this post, and found it very interesting since I have also been learning to lead. I am thoroughly enjoying leading, it is challenging but so rewarding when done musically.
People often ask whether its difficult to switch from being a leader / follower. So far I haven’t found it difficult. I learnt to dance as a follower about 18 months ago, I love the music and wanted to learn a different way of interpreting it, hence the leading. I particularly enjoy leading Milonga. I want to learn the fundamentals with good technique. I have no desire to learn complicated steps- just the basics and how to get round obstacles musically(for now anyway).
I do find my confidence in leading is not that great compared to when I learnt to be a follower – I wonder why?
Good luck with your leading.
Hello Sharn,
Thanks for sharing your experience on this topic of ‘being the boy’.
I hope that one day I will be able to show the women in my arms a glimpse of what I feel when I dance with my favourite milongueros! I know it can only ever be a glimpse, but it can be a joyful and musical glimpse all the same. One thing I am loving is the experience of how each woman feels to me in the dance… each so different, so amazing, so unique, so scared, so backing off, so present, so distracted, so strong, so scattered, so off-balance, so in-a-hurry, so decisive, so quiet, so still, so heavy, so light, so… oh it gives me a sneak peak into the man’s tango world (and the tango world of other women); utterly fascinating.
I’ve learned to see it all as a journey so confidence is less of an issue for me than it was when I was learning to dance as a woman, it’s more about enjoying myself now and making my partners feel good, and I will walk to the ends of the tango earth to make sure I am doing that… a lifetime of practice lies ahead!
I wish you well on your own tango journeys both as a woman and as ‘the boy’.
Un abrazo, SC
Well, I already appreciate, the tango-girl part, since I follow, too. *warm smile* Also, it has made me a better leader, for sure, in understanding the woman’s role of follower.
20 comments